The 100 Greatest Different Songs of the Nineteen Nineties » PopMatters
Beforehand, we introduced you the “100 Greatest Different Songs of the Nineteen Eighties”, a five-part collection that attracted hundreds of readers worldwide and explored the most effective different music the Nineteen Eighties needed to supply. Now, we transfer ahead in time and study what many think about the “golden age” of different rock, with the “100 Biggest Different Singles of the Nineteen Nineties”.
The understanding of “different” was completely different within the Nineteen Nineties. The time period grew to become extra extensively used, changing such Nineteen Eighties descriptions as faculty rock, indie pop, post-modern, and underground. It additionally exploded in reputation — from large radio stations like WHFS in Washington, DC, and KROQ in Los Angeles to the airwaves of MTV, different music dominated the rock and roll panorama.
Festivals like Lollapalooza and Lilith Truthful cropped up, and different rock bands bought thousands and thousands of albums and headlined arenas, typically with out benefiting a Prime 40 crossover hit. Prime 40 had dwindled nearly solely to R&B, hip-hop, diva ballads, and dance-pop. There was little or no room for rock and roll, and immediately, bands that will have been thought-about mainstream rock and even Prime 40 in prior years have been lumped in underneath the amorphous “different” label.
A phrase about labels: clearly, “different” is a label with an infinite umbrella. Different sub-genres like “grunge” and “Britpop” grew to become a crutch for lazy writers who couldn’t consider the rest to say a few track or an artist. They have been phony actions invented by the press to explain music that was superficially related. Generally, it might probably’t be helped, however with only a few exceptions, I’ve averted utilizing these labels when potential, as they’re arbitrary, typically misused, and don’t actually say something in regards to the track itself.
In compiling this listing, the primary query one asks is easy: what’s “different”? It’s not a query with a simple reply. In some ways, it’s within the ear of the beholder. One individual’s “different” is one other fan’s “mainstream rock” or “pop” — we’re working in shades of gray. “Exterior the mainstream” isn’t actually sufficient of a definition. In spite of everything, loads of artists who reside outdoors the restricted universe of Prime 40 radio wouldn’t be thought-about different: people, steel, nation, reggae, bluegrass, orchestral, jazz, blues, some hip-hop, and others. “Different” requires a sure edge, a very adventurous vibe, and a selected sensibility. It’s arduous to pinpoint it precisely, however you already know it once you hear it.
Contemplate a couple of examples. The Wallflowers had six singles hit each the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart and the Billboard Mainstream Rock Chart — however solely two of the six charted increased on Trendy Rock than the Mainstream chart. Their rootsy model sounds extra within the vein of the Band than something different, but they have been lumped into that class.
For our functions right here, we’ve weeded out artists just like the Wallflowers who might have been thought-about “different” on the time of their reputation. Nonetheless, with the good thing about hindsight and an artist’s general profession arc, we all know now they aren’t. From twenty years of reflection, we must always be capable to study what is really different or not as we glance past non permanent labels and consider an artist’s musical arc and profession thread in a bigger context, together with what was acceptable to Prime 40 radio. It’s all in regards to the massive image.
Different artists that obtained heavy airplay on different radio within the Nineteen Nineties however on reflection appear extra like mainstream rock or pop embody Sheryl Crow, Third Eye Blind, Sarah McLachlan, Gin Blossoms, Shawn Colvin, Toad the Moist Sprocket, Paula Cole, Joan Osborne, Matthew Candy, Sophie B. Hawkins, Semisonic, Collective Soul, and plenty of others. There isn’t a query that each one of those artists recorded nice songs and will have as soon as been thought-about different, however with the passage of time, we are able to see issues extra clearly. Thus, they aren’t included right here.
Others, like Large Assault, the Prodigy, the Shamen, Chemical Brothers, Underworld, DJ Shadow, Sunscreem, and Tough, match extra comfortably within the realm of electronica. After all, many of those artists blur the traces of a number of genres, and there aren’t any arduous and quick guidelines to find out that are “different” or not. Generally, it’s merely a judgment name.
The Billboard Trendy Rock Chart is a useful information however not a definitive reference. Many artists who’re clearly not different have appeared on the chart because it debuted in September 1988, together with the Rolling Stones (twice), Seal, Lenny Kravitz, Ace of Base, Tom Petty, Enya, Rickie Lee Jones, John Hiatt, Deee-Lite, Paul Simon, Chris Isaak, Dire Straits (twice), Robbie Robertson, Terence Trent D’Arby, Shaggy, and the Rembrandts for his or her much-reviled theme from Associates, “I’ll Be There For You”.
Even Hootie & The Blowfish and Proper Mentioned Fred’s “I’m Too Attractive” made the Trendy Rock chart. The chart is only one piece of knowledge to think about and positively not the figuring out issue as as to if or not a track makes the listing or the place it ought to be ranked. One certainty: probably the most profitable track doesn’t at all times correlate to being the “biggest” track. Usually, it doesn’t.
So, how have been the songs chosen? Initially, there was a listing of a number of hundred songs that have been potential candidates. Every was critically thought-about. As with the Nineteen Eighties listing, just one track per artist is chosen. The listing continued to develop together with the vast web that was solid for the in depth analysis behind this venture. Ultimately, the winnowing started, and — in a really painful train that concerned reducing some genuinely wonderful songs — the ultimate 100 have been compiled.
Creative worth is probably the most crucial consider choosing a track, and cultural significance and affect are additionally thought-about. This listing is reserved for songs that have been launched as some type of single, whether or not industrial or promotional.
Some artists launched critically hailed albums which are unquestionably important recordings of the Nineteen Nineties however didn’t have a standout single that calls for inclusion, or in some instances had no singles in any respect — examples embody Uncle Tupelo’s No Despair, Slint’s Spiderland, Speak Speak’s Laughing Inventory, Magnetic Fields’ 69 Love Songs, Dismemberment Plan’s Emergency & I, Spiritualized Girls and Gents We Are Floating in Area and Belle and Sebastian’s If You’re Feeling Sinister amongst many others. Their exclusion right here shouldn’t lead one to deduce that these aren’t thought-about important albums of the Nineteen Nineties, however it is a singles listing. An albums listing might need a really completely different roster of artists.
It’s a on condition that many nice songs usually are not included. 100 is an unforgiving quantity. Think about, in a decade with as many killer different tracks because the Nineteen Nineties, choosing on common solely ten singles per yr; 1995 alone might simply yield a listing of 100 traditional different tracks. Contemplating the variables concerned in deciding what’s in reality “different”, which songs ought to be included by a selected artist, after which figuring out the best way to rank them, there are lots of selections to be made.
I labored very arduous to be as goal as potential in an train that’s subjective by its very nature. After all, this isn’t supposed to be a catch-all of the great different singles of the Nineteen Nineties. That will require a way more in depth listing. That is simply the very tip of a large and fantastic iceberg.
Finally, this piece is one snapshot of a outstanding decade and an homage to the good music that emerged from this period. Everybody else who lived by this era of music and loves it might need a unique imaginative and prescient of it. Even when you disagree with the listing, absolutely we are able to, at minimal, have fun this phenomenal time in different music and these 100 genuinely improbable songs.
Particular because of Gina Gerard for her invaluable suggestions, editorial and ethical help, and to Andrew Tinker, the wonderful copy-editing machine, for his tireless help. Additionally, many because of Michael English, Malcolm Lee, Christopher McKay, and Daniel Miron for editorial suggestions.
100. 311 – “Down” (1995)
311 launched their self-titled third album in the course of the summer time of 1995, however it actually blasted off the next yr, thanks largely to its audacious second single, “Down”. It’s a slice of hyper-kinetic rock, the stressed groove of youth within the type of three potent minutes of radioactive spunk. 311 blends genres seamlessly, incorporating parts of rock, hip-hop, steel, and even reggae into their sound. They do it so naturally it sounds easy. “Down” is supposed as a ‘thanks’ to 311’s followers who helped carry the band from small-town midwestern obscurity to multi-platinum success.
“Down” is constructed on hot-wired guitar, skittery drumwork, turntable scratches that zip round like ninja knives, and a brash dancehall-inspired vocal by Nick Hexum. The band recorded the track reside within the studio and delivered a knockout efficiency bristling with swagger and power. 311 is the kind of skater-rock band critics like to hate, however generally people neglect what rock and roll has at all times been about: angle. 311 delivers loads of that, with spectacular musical chops to again it up.
“Down” spent 4 weeks at #1 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart in the course of the fall of 1996, properly over a yr after the album’s launch. Together with the 2 different singles “All Blended Up” and “Don’t Keep House”, “Down” helped 311 transfer over three million models — the band’s greatest promoting album by far.
99. Heather Nova – “Stroll This World” (1994)
The lead single from Bermuda-born singer/songwriter Heather Nova’s second album Oyster is “Stroll This World”, a dramatic acoustic rocker bleeding with need. It opens with a fast guitar snarl earlier than launching right into a descending bass sample that types the spine of the verses, generally anchored with a delicate cello (which I used to be listening to as a baritone sax all these years).
Nova’s breathy vocals intensify the sense of desperation in her seek for which means and connection — for somebody to assist navigate life’s unpredictable maze of travails. It’s not simple to belief, as she’s clearly been scarred by previous expertise and has constructed up a wall: “I’m sucked in by the surprise / and that i’m fucked up by the lies / and I dig a gap to climb in / and I construct some wings to fly”. She’s taking an opportunity, laying herself naked, prepared to strive once more — maybe among the desperation comes with the thought that she won’t get one other likelihood.
Nova weaves a deft melody in the course of the refrain, her multi-tracked vocals simmering with urgency as she sings, “I’m not touched, however I’m aching to be”. The track doesn’t have a bridge per se, only a dreamy instrumental interlude with a double-tracked electrical guitar that bends subtly, as if underwater. The environment is turbulent and unsure as Nova grapples with an unrequited want.
Though Heather Nova has continued to launch one stable album after one other, “Stroll This World” was her solely substantial hit (thus far) — it reached #13 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart.
98. Butthole Surfers – “Pepper” (1996)
Veteran fringe-rockers Butthole Surfers scored a shock hit with “Pepper”, an oddity within the band’s primarily experimental hardcore catalog. It’s not obscure why “Pepper” linked with a big viewers — it’s a splendidly surreal slow-motion acid journey that blurs the traces between “Strawberry Fields Perpetually” and Paul’s Boutique. Gibby Haynes deadpans the spoken-word lyrics in the course of the verses, gusting wind audible within the background, after which jolts us again to consideration in the course of the hard-rock refrain. “Pepper’s” sonic universe consists of backward guitar, tremolo results in the course of the refrain, bizarre vocalisms and different bits of ingenious reality-twisting.
The lyrics cope with random likelihood, as Haynes relates an oddball solid of characters and their generally lethal foibles (impressed by his youthful reminiscences within the Texas punk-rock scene): “One other Mikey took a knife whereas arguing in site visitors / Flipper died a pure demise he caught a nasty virus / then there was the ever-present soccer participant rapist / they have been all in love with dying, they have been doin’ it in Texas.”
“Pepper” was a breakthrough single from the band’s Electriclarryland album, spending three weeks at #1 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart in the course of the summer time of ’96. Self-destruction and document firm troubles prevented the band from constructing on the track’s momentum, and “Pepper” stays a solitary bubble that by some means floated to the floor of a backwoods Texas swamp and popped onto the airwaves.
97. Morphine – “Remedy For Ache” (1993)
No one sounded fairly like Morphine. The Boston-based band, led by singer and bassist Marc Sandman, adopted their very own guidelines about what rock and roll ought to be. They perfected a sound by which electrical guitar isn’t the driving issue. Sandman was well-known for his oddly-tuned two-string bass guitar, which he typically performed with a slide. Dana Colley’s deep and resonant sax dealt with the principle instrumental hooks and solos. Two drummers performed for the band at varied instances: Billy Conway and Jerome Deupree. The band’s uncommon bottom-heavy sound thrilled critics however by no means lifted them past cult standing within the US, though they loved some industrial success in Europe.
The woozy “Remedy for Ache” is the band’s second album title monitor. The track is relaxed sufficient to have popped a couple of Xanax, however the necessity for self-medicating to numb no matter ache Sandman is experiencing is laid out starkly. Even on this darkness Sandman by no means loses his acerbic humorousness: “I suggest a toast to my self-control / you see it crawling helpless on the ground”. The wry couplet makes clear that the prospect of quitting medication is painful sufficient to justify persevering with on his damaging path, however he understands it’s what it’s.
Sadly, Morphine would stop to exist in 1999 when Sandman died immediately of a coronary heart assault at age 46 whereas on stage at a live performance in Italy. Morphine left behind an amazing musical legacy, with “Remedy for Ache” first dose for the uninitiated.
96. Soul Asylum – “Someone to Shove” (1992)
“Someone to Shove” is a searing garage-rocker from Minneapolis-based Soul Asylum’s sixth album Grave Dancer’s Union, by far their most profitable launch. Dave Pirner’s stressed vocals trip together with the churning guitar riff earlier than lastly ripping free in the course of the raucous refrain. The efficiency is tight — drummer Grant Younger (or extra seemingly Sterling Campbell, who producer Michael Beinhorn introduced in as a result of he was dissatisfied with Younger’s performances) amps up the power and offers a rock-solid basis.
Pirner’s lyrics jive with the track’s fidgety tone as he sits in despondent boredom, craving for somebody to stir him into some sort of motion that can tear by his sullen malaise. Lengthy days that fade endlessly into each other with nothing ever taking place, a life spent watching the clock flip day after day after day — Pirner completely captures the frantic want to flee the incessant tedium.
“Someone to Shove” rocks and grooves with manic abandon, a runaway prepare of strain that lastly bursts right into a match of frustration. His desperation heats to a boil because the track hits its climax: “And I’m ready by the cellphone / Ready so that you can name me and inform me I’m not alone / Sure, I’m ready by the cellphone / I’m waitin’ so that you can name me, name me / And inform me I’m / Inform me I’m not alone!” It’s arduous to not be struck by the sturdy suspicion that the decision ain’t ever gonna come.
The primary of 4 main hits from Grave Dancer’s Union (together with “Black Gold”, “With no Hint”, and “Runaway Practice”), “Someone to Shove” hit #1 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart in December 1992. Soul Asylum’s killer efficiency of the track on MTV Unplugged stays probably the greatest moments in that collection’ historical past.
95. The Jesus and Mary Chain – “Reverence” (1993)
The Jesus and Mary Chain’s fourth album Honey’s Lifeless was so named as a result of the Scottish duo needed to serve discover they’d expanded past the boundaries of their breakthrough single “Simply Like Honey” from their landmark 1985 debut Psychocandy. Paradoxically, there are sturdy echoes of that traditional track within the distorted guitar and electro-rock of “Reverence”, the edgy and provocative first single which grew to become an inconceivable Prime 10 hit within the UK.
With its repeated calls of “I wish to die identical to Jesus Christ”, “Reverence” incorporates a gritty industrial vibe, heavy digital beats, and dense snarls of reverbed guitar. Jim Reid’s tense vocals are deep within the combine, nearly buried by the abrasive sonic equipment as if he’s coated in grime from crawling on a manufacturing facility ground. The track is a name to go down in a blaze of glory, to be mythologized in demise like Jesus Christ and JFK. Reid equates these two fabled figures with rock stars whose deaths carry close to deification and reverence that turns into, in some instances, greater and extra substantial than the music itself.
94. Rancid – “Time Bomb” (1995)
Amped with fitful power, the ska/rock alloy “Time Bomb” was the second single from Rancid’s finest album, …And Out Come the Wolves. Rancid rose from the ashes of Operation Ivy, an influential ska band that by no means broke by to a broad viewers however helped form the thriving Nineteen Nineties ska scene with bands like Pietasters, Mighty Mighty Bosstones, Reel Large Fish, and others.
“Time Bomb” is a compact little tablet that you simply swallow and immediately really feel like bouncing round like a haywire kangaroo. The track describes a man who’s unpredictable in all of the worst methods, ready to blow up as he slides out and in of a lifetime of hazard and crime. Tim Armstrong’s husky vocals are so slurred generally you could barely make them out with out a lyric sheet, however it solely provides to the track’s bedraggled realness. It’s clear these guys would know a time bomb after they see one.
All the pieces on “Time Bomb” strikes with supercharged velocity. The infectious rhythm is bolstered by rolling whirls of organ, and the straightforward guitar solo cuts by the bedlam briefly earlier than we dive shortly again into the implacable groove. Clocking in at solely 2:24, “Time Bomb” is a good musical punch and one catchy sufficient to pogo round in your mind for days. It hit #8 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart, Rancid’s highest-ever placement on that survey, and the monitor sounds as contemporary and alive because the day it was baked.
93. Jars of Clay – “Flood” (1995)
Non secular ache and doubt can lead to deeply compelling artwork, whether or not by music or one other medium — even when one doesn’t subscribe to the beliefs being espoused. Faith can eat one’s coronary heart, thoughts, and soul. In the event you imagine all the way down to your bones that you’re an inherently flawed sinner in want of a jealous God’s forbearance, you would possibly certainly think about your self “one with the mud” as Jars of Clay singer/songwriter Dan Haseltine does on the band’s epic single “Flood”. The track is clearly wrenched from deepest despair: “Downpour on my soul / splashing within the ocean, I’m shedding management / darkish sky throughout / I can’t really feel my toes touching the bottom.”
Taken from the Tennessee-based up to date Christian band’s self-titled debut, “Flood” grew to become an unlikely hit on different radio. The track is a torrent of the kind of guilt upon which religions flourish. The refrain, wealthy with vocal harmonies, hangs on a single word — ratcheting up the stress whereas we await reduction that by no means comes.
“Flood” finds Haseltine on his knees, begging for redemption, beseeching his God to avoid wasting him from “drowning once more”. It’s one in every of two tracks (together with very good “Liquid”) from the band’s debut masterfully produced by the good Adrian Belew. From the delicate results on Haseltine’s vocal to the glistening string part within the track’s center to the hard-driving acoustic guitar riffs which ring like heavy sheets of black rain on the pavement, “Flood” is musically evocative of the emotional tumult Haseltine expresses within the lyrics.
Jars of Clay would go on to attain quite a few hits on Christian radio whereas typically straddling the road between secular and religious, however “Flood” was their solely substantial crossover success — it reached #12 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart.
92. Indigo Ladies – “Galileo” (1997)
We go from beseeching an all-knowing spirit to entreating an emblem of science and rational thought who was persecuted for educating beliefs that contradicted spiritual dictates however has since been vindicated by historical past. The superbly lush “Galileo” was the second single from Indigo Ladies’ fourth album, Rites of Passage, and has turn out to be one of many extremely influential duo’s signature tunes. Emily Saliers wrote the track and sings with swish poignancy, whereas associate Amy Ray offers beautiful harmonies (additionally joined by rock legend David Crosby).
Produced by Peter Collins, a well-traveled rock veteran who was on the helm of a lot of Canadian rock titans Rush’s biggest works, “Galileo” builds to a stirring climax with a swirl of harmonious vocals over the syncopated rhythm. The bridge glows with pulsing strings, after which a beautiful twin acoustic guitar solo leads into the ultimate verse and refrain. The ending is a whirlwind of sound that closes the track with a fascinating flourish.
“Galileo” is a daydream about reincarnation, a question as to when “my soul will get it proper”, and a name to the famed astronomer and truth-seeker Galileo for celestial steering. It’s a fantasy that’s sparked by that all-too-human impulse of imagining a unique and higher life within the wake of failures and troubles that appear to overwhelm our present existence and our innate surprise in regards to the mysteries of the afterlife and the place we match within the universe.
“Galileo” is an expansive track that asks massive questions however is carried out with intimate sincerity and wonder. It grew to become the long-lasting duo’s highest-ever chart exhibiting within the US, reaching #10 on the Billboard Trendy Rock Chart.
91. Sparklehorse – “Sick of Goodbyes” (1998)
Mark Linkous had a present for candy melodies swaddled in darkish swirls of melancholy. Good Morning Spider was the second album Linkous launched underneath the Sparklehorse title. It was written and recorded after his near-fatal overdose attributable to mixing alcohol with the remedy he took to battle his crippling despair, and the album unquestionably bares these scars.
Good Morning Spider radiates otherworldly magnificence, fragility, and an undercurrent of despair. “Sick of Goodbyes” is one in every of its most fast and compelling tracks. Linkous co-wrote the track with fellow Virginian David Lowery of Cracker, whose comparatively drab recording appeared on their 1993 album Kerosene Hat. Linkous was smart to take it again and get probably the most out of it. The Sparklehorse model is melodic and fascinating with an insistent groove, a chiming wall of sound from the fusion of acoustic and electrical guitars, and, weaving by all of it, a thick alien drone pulsing from an outdated analog synth.
The lyrics are poetic however relentlessly bleak: “The evening comes crawling in on all fours / sucking up my desires by the ground,” Linkous sings at one level. There’s an nearly wry resignation to the track, no spark of hope that change for the higher is within the playing cards, at the very least on this “vampire planet”. “Sick of Goodbyes” is wrenching unhappiness wrapped in a glow of a heartbreaking magnificence that you simply by some means know is non permanent.
After years of attempting to deal with debilitating despair and habit, Mark Linkous took his personal life in March 2010, one other within the seemingly infinite string of casualties of despair and habit that has been such a blight on society within the Nineteen Nineties and past. It’s arduous to listen to him sing, “I’m so sick of goodbyes, goodbyes,” and never suppose, “So are we”.